Peer Review Policy
Model
Research articles, reviews and case studies undergo double-blind peer review: authors and reviewers do not know each other's identities. Editorials, perspectives and book reviews may be reviewed only by the editors, and this is stated on the article.
Process
- The editorial office runs a technical check: completeness, anonymisation, formatting and similarity screening.
- The Editor-in-Chief or a Senior Editor screens the manuscript for scope and quality and may decline it without review.
- A handling Editor invites at least two independent reviewers.
- Reviewers submit structured reports with a recommendation within 21 days.
- The handling Editor recommends a decision, and the Editor-in-Chief decides: accept, minor revision, major revision or reject.
- Revised manuscripts are usually returned to the original reviewers.
Reviewer selection
Reviewers must have relevant expertise and no conflict of interest. They must not come from the authors' own institution or have collaborated with the authors in the past three years. Authors may suggest or oppose reviewers. Editors are not bound by these suggestions.
Editors' own papers
Manuscripts by an editor of the journal are handled entirely by another editor, and the authoring editor has no access to the review. The article records this.
Reviewer conduct
- Who reviews: independent external experts in the subject or methods, never members of the editorial office. Editorial board members may review only when they are not handling the manuscript.
- Number of reviews: at least two per research manuscript.
- Anonymity: reviewers do not see author identities, and authors do not see reviewer identities. Reviews are not signed and are not published with articles. Editors' decision letters and authors' responses are not published.
- Confidentiality: manuscripts are confidential. Reviewers must not contact the authors. They may involve a colleague only with the editor's prior permission, and the colleague is named to the editor.
- AI: reviewers must not upload manuscripts into, or use, generative AI tools to write or edit their reviews.
- Assignment: reviewers are chosen and invited by the handling editor, not by automated or AI tools. Author-suggested reviewers only widen the pool, and editors are not bound by them.
- Supplementary material is reviewed together with the manuscript.
Timelines
Reviewers are asked to report within 21 days. We aim for a first decision within 6–8 weeks of submission, and each article shows its received, accepted and published dates. If a manuscript is delayed, we tell the authors why and offer them the option to withdraw it.
Exceptions
If an article in a normally peer-reviewed category did not undergo peer review, the article page says so. Editors receive guidance on selecting reviewers, recognising conflicts of interest, handling inappropriate reviewer comments and communicating revision requests.