Conflicts of Interest
A conflict of interest exists when a relationship or interest could influence, or appear to influence, someone's judgment about a manuscript.
- Authors declare every relevant financial interest (funding, employment, consultancy, shares, fees) and non-financial interest (personal, political, academic) from the past 3 years. Declarations are published.
- Reviewers decline invitations when they have a conflict: for example a recent collaboration with the authors, the same institution, competing work, or a personal relationship.
- Editors declare their interests on appointment in the Editorial Agreement, update them when they change, and recuse themselves from conflicted manuscripts.
What counts as a conflict
Financial interests (funding, employment, consultancy, honoraria, shares, patents); personal relationships; political or religious beliefs that may be relevant; academic or professional rivalry or collaboration; and ownership interests in organisations affected by the work.
How and when to declare
- Authors declare all interests on the title page when submitting, and update the declaration if anything changes before publication.
- Reviewers declare interests before accepting an invitation. If a conflict emerges during review, they tell the editor and stop.
- Editors declare interests when appointed and annually afterwards. They recuse themselves from decisions on manuscripts where they have a conflict, and the manuscript is reassigned.
- The journal and the publisher declare their own interests when relevant, for example in articles about ACRI or its initiatives.
If a conflict was not declared
Before publication, the manuscript may be returned, re-reviewed or rejected. After publication, a correction is published. If the undeclared interest calls the findings into question, an expression of concern or retraction may follow, in line with COPE guidance.
Editors and staff are never paid according to the number of articles accepted.